BRUSSELS, Belgium — The European Union's food safety
agency approved two genetically modified corns Friday, putting
renewed pressure on EU nations to drop their objections to
the use of biotech crops.
Scientists at the Parma, Italy-based European Food Safety
Authority, or EFSA gave clearance to a Bt-11 corn seed made
by Switzerland's Syngenta AG and the 1507 corn made by the
U.S.-based Pioneer Hi-Bred and Dow Agrosciences.
Both varieties offer resistance to insects, including corn
borers and certain butterflies. They were already deemed safe
by the agency in 2005, but were resubmitted for testing by
the EU Commission in May amid fresh claims by environmental
groups that they were a threat to the environment and human
health.
The EU agency also said a French ban on another GM corn product,
produced by U.S. biotech giant Monsanto Co., was unjustified.
The EU granted approval to sell the seeds in the bloc in 2004.
Mike Hall, spokesman for Pioneer, welcomed the panel's opinion.
"This dossier has already been unduly delayed contrary
to EU legislation for nearly four years now and we urge the
speedy approval of 1507 so that European farmers can benefit," Hall
said.
It will now be up to the European Commission to decide whether
to issue the companies licenses to sell the products in the
27-nation bloc.The issue poses a headache for the Commission,
which is trying to force reluctant EU governments to drop some
national GM crop bans, amid increasing global pressure from
Europe's trade partners.
The panel's decisions sparked a strong reaction from environmental
group Greenpeace, which called on the EU to suspend the agency's
power to issue safety checks until a full review of how the
EU approves GM crops is done.
Greenpeace claims more research is needed to assess the long-term
impact of altered crops on the environment and human health
and alleges the scientist panel ignored evidence that the two
crops could have a bad effect on biodiversity and the environment.
"EFSA is becoming the laughing stock of the scientific
community. Rubber stamping anything the agro-biotech industry
puts forward, with the blessing of the European Commission,
is destroying its credibility," said Marta Vetier of Greenpeace.
EU countries are currently debating whether to change the
way the bloc decides on granting user licenses to GM crops
and seeds.
Many member states, including Greece, Austria, Poland and
France are hesitant to adopt new crops fearing environmental
consequences. Under EU rules member states have to approve
new licenses unanimously. If they can't, the EU's executive
commission makes the decision on behalf of all countries.