Brussels (Reuters) - Europe's food safety chief will soon
suggest allowing "very limited" amounts of genetically
modified material not yet permitted in EU markets to be mixed
in imports of foods like maize, rice and soya, she said on
Monday.
Her proposal comes as one of the results of a tortuous debate
held last month at the highest levels of the European Commission
-- the EU executive -- on how to move forward on GMO policy
and end years of deadlock between EU countries.
That may change later this year, as EU Health Commissioner
Androulla Vassiliou prepares a legal proposal that, provided
EU farm ministers agree, would set a ceiling for the amount
of unauthorised GM material which could be tolerated in imports.
"The problem is zero tolerance," Vassiliou told
Reuters in an interview. "We are not talking about big
numbers, we are talking about very limited (amounts) which
are already difficult to detect because they are so limited."
That ceiling would certainly be less than 1.0 percent, she
said, adding that the proposal should be issued by early August.
At present, EU law sets a tolerance threshold of 0.9 percent
for GM material in food and feed, above which a cargo must
be labelled as being biotech.
EU feedmakers have long complained of problems sourcing raw
material, warning that the consequences of Europe's extreme
caution and "zero tolerance" of unauthorised GMOs,
even in tiny amounts, could be catastrophic for the food and
feed sectors.
The problem for GM crop-growing countries, in particular the
United States, Canada and Argentina, is that EU law at the
moment does not tolerate the accidental presence of unauthorised
GMOs that have been approved elsewhere.
That has led to cargoes of rice and grain arriving at EU ports
being impounded by local authorities if sampling shows the
presence of unauthorised GM material, disrupting trade flows.
TEMPORARY SOLUTION
Europe has long been criticised by major GMO producers like
the United States for its reluctance to embrace biotech foods.
No new GMOs have been approved for growing in EU countries
since 1998, in large part because of huge public resistance
to what are sometimes called "Frankenstein foods."
Commission experts say the EU takes a minimum of 2.5 years,
and often longer, to complete new GMO approvals compared with
an average of 15 months in the United States, causing a time-lag
in equivalent GMO approvals.
"It (threshold proposal) will not be a permanent solution,
just a temporary solution to the problem," Vassiliou said.
"It's not a deviation from our basic legislation which
is in order to authorise a GMO, we have to be absolutely sure
of the safety of the product," she said.
EU livestock producers do depend heavily on imported soy products
-- beans, meal -- as a source of protein-rich and high-quality
feed. Nearly all of it comes from Argentina, Brazil and the
United States, the world's top three soybean producers.
Since these countries mainly grow GM varieties, non-biotech
soy is becoming increasingly difficult to source, they say.