With one in three Filipinos subsisting on nutrient-deficient
but cheap instant noodles, the Philippines is pinning its hopes
on "Frankenstein food" to feed its impoverished millions
despite environmental and health worries.
Agriculture Secretary Domingo Panganiban said the government
has been aggressively promoting genetically modified [GM]
crops for widespread cultivation in order to boost food production.
"When your land area [for agriculture production] is
getting smaller and your population is growing, then we have
to resort to technologies ... to produce double than what
was being produced in a given land," he said.
Panganiban said the Philippines is among the 12 countries
in the world where over 85 percent of land is already under
the most "intense use for agriculture, housing and industry."
The agriculture department was encouraged by the response
of Filipino farmers in cultivating Bacillus thuringiensis
(Bt) corn, the first GM crop introduced in the country five
years ago.
Panganiban said the number of farmers growing the genetically
modified Bt corn has increased tremendously, with the area
of production now at 25,000 hectares, out of at least 250,000
hectares devoted to the crop.
"From the ordinary hybrid to Bt, there was a quantum
leap in terms of adoption, especially for corn-growing areas
in the southern region of Mindanao," he told a recent
meeting of regional biotechnology experts in Manila.
"Farmers who adopted it at the initial phase have earned
more than those who still cling to the old varieties," he
added.
But the Bt corn production in the Philippines has also been
met with opposition from some farmer and environmental groups,
such as Greenpeace.
Greenpeace has warned Filipinos that the so-called "Frankenfood" --
or products whose inherent qualities have been artificially
manipulated in a bid to produce goods with improved genetic
traits -- could be harmful.
"Because the technology is very new and imprecise,
the potential ill effects on public health and on the environment
are still widely unknown," it said. "The truth
is no one knows for sure how these new manmade creations
will affect life on planet Earth."
Senator Miriam Defensor Santiago cautioned the government
against embracing biotechnology as the panacea to poverty,
which plagues one-third of the country's more than 85 million
people.
Santiago said GM crops might pose risks to human health,
citing a genetically modified corn, called Starlink, that
was declared by the US Environmental Protection Agency as
unfit for human consumption because it reportedly aggravates
allergies.
"GMOs [genetically modified organisms] can have devastating
effects on indigenous and local communities," she said. "They
might also create dependence on multinational corporations."
But World Bank economist Kim Anderson said studies conducted
by scientists and experts around the globe have shown that
GMOs under current cultivation do not pose a hazard to human
health or to the environment.
Anderson said GM crops released for commercial production
were so far environment-friendly since these are pest-resistant
and no longer dependent on pesticides.
"Some of the best scientific reports that have looked
into the issue [biotechnology] from Europe, including from
academies of sciences, all of them have not been able to
find significant environmental or food safety concerns with
the products of this technology," he said.
Anderson noted that a lot of concerns and issues raised
against biotechnology were due to misunderstanding and ignorance.
"I think anti-GM0 groups often, when you force them
to the issue, they are not so much anti-GMOs. They are anti
other issues, like globalization," he said.
Clive James, chairman of the International Service for the
Acquisition of Agri-Biotech applications, said that last
year -- the 10th year anniversary of commercialization of
GMOs -- a total of 90 million hectares of land worldwide
were allocated to the so-called Frankenstein crops.
He added that 1.8 million farmers from 21 countries, including
France, Portugal and Czech Republic, have already shifted
to cultivating GMOs.
Agriculture Undersecretary Segfredo Serrano, who directly
oversees the Philippines' biotechnology program, said a regulatory
system to monitor GMOs was in place in the country.
"We are the first country in the region to establish
[a regulatory system]," he said. "The process is
very transparent. It involves purely scientific objective
methods. There are independent scientists to do the assessment
of risks."
Panganiban said that with the success of the Bt corn, the
government was looking forward to the introduction of genetically
modified rice within the next two years as well as genetically
modified cotton, vegetables and fruits.
"There are now over 85 million Filipinos," he
said. "By the end of this year 2 million more will have
been born. And because of dwindling farmlands, a vast number
of our farmers are counted among the poorest in the Asia-Pacific
region."
"Biotechnology is the rightful answer to that," Panganiban
added.