GENERAL SANTOS CITY -- Claiming genetically modified organisms
are "very much safe," a government-backed biotechnology
advocacy group has declared that the Philippines no longer needs
to label various food and other consumer products that contain
the controversial genetically-modified (GM) products.
Dr. Benigno Peczon, president of the Manila-based Biotechnology
Coalition of the Philippines Inc., pointed out that "conclusive
studies" made by scientists and medical experts worldwide
have substantially affirmed the safety of the GM products.
"Why label if these products are in fact safe? (Labeling
them) doesn't make sense," he told reporters in a biotechnology
forum in Alabel, Sarangani last week.
Peczon said labeling the GM products is not practical since
it would only increase their prices by 10 to 12 percent and
these would eventually be borne by the consumers.
He particularly cited products such as the wheat-based infant
food, beverages, canola oil and potato chips that are currently
being sold in the local markets
He said the cost of production of these products would increase
due to the additional costs on the segregation of the raw materials
or ingredients, the testing of the contents and their storage.
"This will pose a big problem since average Filipinos
spend at least 60 percent of their income on food," Peczon
said.
According to an impact study on the "cost implications
of GM food labeling" released last year by the Bureau of
Food and Drugs Administration, the mandatory GM labeling "will
have a devastating impact on the viability of corporations,
unless the incidence of costs can be passed on to consumers
in terms of higher selling price of finished food products."
The study indicated that "GM-free soy and corn-based food
products will cost 10 percent to 12 percent more with the percentage
of the raw material cost to the selling price at 30 percent,
20 percent for sales and marketing cost, manufacturing cost,
10 percent and packaging cost, one percent."
In 2001, the House of Representatives passed a bill requiring
the labeling of GM-derived food and food products but it failed
to get the national government's nod.
Marikina Rep. Del de Guzman introduced the "Genetically
Engineered Food Right to Know Act," which demands that
food and food products containing genetically modified organisms
or those produced through genetic engineering technologies be
labeled as such.
Peczon said his group, which was created as an offshoot of
the Department of Trade and Industry's efforts to develop the
country's biotechnology sector, believes that a government's
decision on whether GM products should be labeled or not is
no longer necessary since GMOs have been proven to be safe.
He said government has already acknowledged the safety of GM
products and that even adopted the development of biotechnology
as a major government policy.
Last year, several groups opposed to the genetically-engineered
Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) corn mounted their campaign against
the crop following claims by a Norwegian scientist that several
residents from Sitio Kalyong, barangay Landan in Polomolok,
South Cotabato, where Bt corn had been planted, could have been
exposed to the Bt toxin.
Dr. Terje Traviik, a scientist from the Norwegian Institute
of Gene Ecology, said a study on the blood samples 39 B'laan
residents from the area yielded positive of exposure to Bt toxin.
In August 2003, about 100 residents from Sitio Kalyong were
documented to have been suffering from headache, dizziness,
extreme stomach pain, vomiting and allergies, about three months
after local farmers planted some hectares with Monsanto's Yieldgard
818, the firm's Bt corn variety.
But Peczon, who was among the medical experts sent by the government
to the area last year to look into the matter, claimed that
Traviik had already acknowledged his mistake in issuing such
findings to the public last year.
"He (Traviik) reportedly admitted in a recent briefing
that what he released then were premature findings and he even
parried further questions about it," he added.