Philippines
COMMENTARY:
BALI AND Bt CORN
by Denis Murphy
 
As a boy growing up in an Irish-American family I always wanted to go to Ireland. After all the stories I heard at home I thought it must be a beautiful place, filled with brave and witty people, full of the past and poetry. It wasn't quite like that when I finally had a chance to go there, but it was never disappointing, even when it rained for days on end. 

From the time I came to Asia years ago I wanted to visit Bali, where nature and people were said to live in perfect harmony amid old traditions, beautiful women, dances and temples. When I finally received an invitation to visit Bali it was to attend a meeting on globalization of the economy. I thought it was funny. How could such an abstract topic be discussed in paradise? 

We soon learned Bali was the perfect place for such a discussion since it teaches what is most needed in the struggle against uncontrolled free trade and foreign control, namely, faithfulness to a traditional way of life and traditional values. In Bali, for example, people continue to design their homes the old way with priority given to the family temple; they grow rice the old way though it costs more than the miracle rice varieties; they have faithfully held on to their old Hindu rites though Hindus are a small minority in a sea of Muslims. They say to the hundreds of thousands of tourists who visit Bali each year: this is what we are; we are proud of what we are. 

In our seminar on globalization, an Indonesian woman talked of its dangers. The rich countries will, unless checked, control the world's food supply (Bt corn, for example), medicines, finance and manufacturing, natural resources (mining), basic services such as water and light (Manila Water Co., Manila Electric Co.), intellectual patents, weapons of war and all political decision-making. She showed a film on the subject in which a US steelworker protesting uncontrolled free trade says, "The one thing the rich want is everything." It was a good summary of her talk. 

The Philippines has a good example of this over-arching power in the Bt-corn controversy in which several people, including my parish priest Father Robert Reyes, are on hunger strike. The fasters are protesting the danger Bt corn poses to other varieties of corn, animals and humans, but it is also a question of control. Does the country want its corn industry and food security controlled by foreign companies, such as Monsanto that now propagates the Bt corn? Does it want its native varieties and, eventually its native growers, to disappear? 

Poor countries do not have to accept foreign control. There are alternatives. "Another world is possible" in the words of the World Social Forum, the response of civil society worldwide to excessive free trade. 

It's not easy to reject Monsanto's efforts here. Father Reyes told the writer that the US Agency for International Development had given the government a loan of 200 million pesos to help the spread of Bt corn. The farmers get free seeds for a year. The promised increases in production are dramatic, but problems are downplayed. 

It comes down to basic values. In Bali the more obvious values have to do with the Balinese remaining themselves no matter who governs them or who arrives by the hundreds of thousands to visit. In the Philippines the basic value has been, unless I'm mistaken, political freedom. The country was the first republic in Asia. More Filipinos died fighting the colonial powers here (Spain and the United States) than died in any other country in the anti-colonial wars. More Filipinos fought the Marcos dictatorship than Koreans fought the dictatorship of Park Chung-hee or Indonesians that of Suharto. 

Maybe if the struggle against Bt corn and the other excesses of the new global economy was seen as a struggle for national liberty, more people here would join in. Time is running out. Some local industries have disappeared already. I met a taxi driver who said he was from the province of Romblon. When I asked how the marble business was, he told me it was nearly crippled by the entry of inexpensive, good quality marble from China that is allowed in now as tariffs are lowered to stimulate free trade.

(Dennis Murphy works with the Urban Poor Associates) 

Other News
 
 
 
The hoopla that is biotecnology (Commentary)
 
 
 
Bali and Bt corn (Commentary)
 
 
 
Oft-asked questions about GM foods
 
 
 
Monsanto assists farmers who failed in hybrid rice
 
 
 
Farmers group launches boycott drive vs Monsanto
 
 
 
Monsanto harvests 1st Bt corn crops sees ok of farmers
 
 
 
False issues on Bt corn
 
 
 
First Bt corn planting set for harvest
 
 
 
Corn soup meal ends 'Bt corn' hunger strike
 
 
 
Iwahig penal farm to produce hybrid rice seeds
 
 
 
Bt corn critics urged to use due process to air opposition
 
 
 
Hunger strike highlights issues surrounding GMOs
 
 
 
Agri sector braces for biotech debate
 
 
 
Angara backs Bt corn for agri sector
 
 
 
Bt corn a biological time bomb
 
 
 
Hunger strikers ask agri chief: act now vs Bt corn
 
 
 
DA turns down Greenpeace bid to ban Bt corn
 
 
 
Local feed industry hails Bt corn ok
 
 
 
Blackmailing Cito
 
 
 
DA finds no scientific basis to halt Bt corn sale
 
 
 
ESP, scientists say no to Bt corn
 
 
 
Bt corn distribution opposed (Opinion)
 
 
 
Aggie won't bar Bt corn: 'running priest' joins fast
 
 
 
Hunger strikers continue to press for moratorium on 'Bt corn'
 
 
 
Groups ask gov't to junk moratorium on Bt corn
 
 
 
A case vs GM crops (Opinion)
 
 
 
Anti-Bt corn hunger strikers get more support; wait for Lorenzo's reply
 
 
 
5 Anti-GMO strikers collapsed
 
 
 
Hunger strike; Bt corn facts; strikers, supporters
 
 
 
More news...