Think organic fruits
and vegetables are free of pesticides? Think again.
Almost one-fourth of
the organic produce in grocery stores could contain traces of pesticides,
including long-banned chemicals like DDT, scientists say.
A Consumers Union-led
study of government-collected data found pesticide residue on 23 percent
of organic fruits and vegetables and on nearly 75 percent of
conventionally grown produce.
The findings don't mean
that any of the produce is unsafe. The residues are seldom even close to
the limits set by the Environmental Protection Agency. "Consumers who
seek to reduce their exposure to pesticide residues can do so reliably by
choosing organic produce," the scientists wrote.
"However, none of the choices available on the market is
completely free of pesticide residues."
The study is being
published Wednesday in the journal Food Additives and Contaminants.
Much of the residues
found in organic crops were of organochlorine pesticides, chemicals
including DDT and chlordane that plants can soak up from the soil decades
after the products were used. Other chemicals could have been applied to
the crops improperly or drifted onto the organic fields from adjacent
farms, the scientists said.
One sample of organic
peaches contained 3.3 parts per million of the pesticide phosmet,
suggesting the crop was sprayed shortly before harvest, the study said.
"You normally
think that organic are the ones without the pesticides," said Vicki
Kirkbride, an Arlington, Va., executive shopping Tuesday at a Fresh Fields
supermarket. A sign in the store said organic foods were "grown
without the use of synthetic pesticides, fungicides or fertilizers."
"It's very
difficult to keep the food from contamination ... but I still say organic
is a good idea," said Rodrigo Hurtado, a Washington physician.
Although organic crops account for just 2 percent of U.S. fruit and
vegetable acreage, the industry has been growing rapidly. Sales of organic
foods reached $7.8 billion in 2000, a 20 percent increase from the year
earlier, according to Packaged Facts, a market research firm.
The study was based on
sampling by the Agriculture Department and the state of California as well
as by the scientists themselves. It did not take into account the many
special pesticides that are approved for organic crops, including sulfur
and bacteria sprays.
Those products are
generally considered less toxic than pesticides used by conventional farms
and government inspectors do not test for them.
However, one natural pesticide used by organic farmers, pyrethrum,
may cause cancer, and another is linked to neurotoxic effects in rats. The
study called for more research on those pesticides.
"Consumers need to
recognize that organic production doesn't mean pesticide-free
production," said Carl Winter, a food toxicologist at the University
of California, Davis.
"The best thing
consumers can do is to eat large amounts of fruits and vegetables,"
he said. "Pesticides allow these to be produced in more abundant
manner, making them more affordable and offering consumers greater
variety."
Some scientists also
have raised concerns about the occurrence of mycotoxins on organic produce
as well as the use of manure as fertilizer, which could carry harmful
bacteria if not prepared properly. Mycotoxins, substances produced by
fungi, can be prevented with the use of conventional pesticides.
The Agriculture
Department data that were examined in the Consumers Union study showed
residues on seven of 30 samples of organic fruit, and 22 of 97 samples of
organic vegetables, or 23 percent of the total organic produce tested.
Nine of 19 samples of organic spinach had pesticide traces, and four of 18
carrot samples.
By comparison,
pesticides were found on 73 percent of the 26,571 samples of conventional
foods that were tested.
"Less is better.
Fewer residues and lower levels of residues are better than higher levels
of residues and more residues," said Edward Groth, a senior scientist
for Consumers Union, publisher of Consumer Reports.
The tests also included
some samples of "green-labeled" foods - fruits and vegetables
that are sold with claims of reduced pesticide use. There were pesticide
residues on about half the samples of those products.
When
the organochlorine chemicals were excluded from the analysis of organic
foods, 13 percent showed positive for conventional pesticides.