NGOs, by the way,
have been known to lie when they are convinced that the lie will help them
push their concerns. For instance, in the debate over genetically-modified
maize plants, various NGOs had been reporting that the pollen of what is
called Bt corn was killing off the monarch butterfly.
Now, a two-year study led by the US Agricultural Research Service (ARS)
that included a group of federal, university and biotechnology industry
scientists has shown definitively that the pollen poses no "immediate
significant risk" to the Monarch or to anything else.
What the NGOs used were preliminary studies: In 1999, researchers from
Cornell University reported that maize genetically engineered with the
bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) to resist the corn-borer pest killed
monarch caterpillars in the laboratory.
In 2000, researchers from Iowa State University said monarch caterpillars
were seven times likelier to die from eating milkweed near GM maize than
those eating milkweed leaves with no GM pollen on them.
The more recent and comprehensive study by the ARS scientists has now
found that, as with everything, if one feeds caterpillars too much bt corn
pollen, it could kill them but that below 1,000 pollen grains per square
centimeter, the caterpillars' weight and survival rate were unaffected.
Above that level the caterpillars were smaller, but they survived as long
as the control group.
ARS reports: "We found that, on average, less than 30 percent of the
pollen that corn produces ends up on milkweed leaves, even when conditions
are perfect, and most of that gets deposited on milkweed within the
cornfield."
But the ARS also reported: "You need to compare the potential for
risk to monarchs from Bt corn with the alternative, which is chemical
insecticide use."
Those chemicals will definitely kill the Monarchs. That's what the
chemicals are supposed to do - kill insects. |